Carrie Underwood Dazzles on Disney Night — But Not Everyone Is Clapping

Three finalists are left standing in the race to become the next American Idol, but the biggest headlines following the Top 5 Disney-themed episode weren’t about the contestants — they were about Carrie Underwood.

The Idol judge turned heads with a bold, Rapunzel-inspired purple gown during the May 12 live show, complete with floral embroidery, silver stilettos, and flowing blonde hair that swept all the way down to her ankles. But while the dress earned praise on Instagram, her judging sparked a storm of criticism.

 Viewers Say Underwood Showed “Favoritism” and Harsh Judging

Underwood joined fellow judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie for a night of high-stakes performances, as the Top 5 contestants each performed two Disney songs — one as a hero, the other as a villain. But when Carrie critiqued Top 3 finalist Jamal Roberts, the tone changed.

Though she complimented his voice, she commented that Jamal “missed an opportunity” to move around and entertain more. Viewers saw it differently — and they didn’t hold back.

“Get rid of her. Her bias is showing,” one fan wrote bluntly.

Another viewer added, “I wish we could vote her off. It’s cringe to watch her play favorites.”

One passionate Jamal supporter said, “She critiques Jamal for standing still, but praises John Foster for doing the exact same thing? That’s not fair.”

Others piled on:

“She definitely didn’t like Jamal.”

“Jelly Roll pleaseeee replace her.”

“You bring fake energy — don’t come back next year.”

 Some Fans Defend Carrie: “She’s Just Doing Her Job”

Not all responses were negative. Some Idol viewers rushed to defend Underwood, praising her judging style and fashion risks.

“You’re still going to get criticized, so do whatever you want 💫 ❤️🔥😸.”

“Loved you as a judge this year — people don’t realize you were dressed as Rapunzel tonight!”

“Carrie, I enjoyed watching you this season. Hope you come back next year!”

Still, the divide was clear — Underwood remains a polarizing figure, drawing both admiration and outrage in equal measure.

 The Top 3 Finalists Are Announced

As tension escalated on stage, Ryan Seacrest announced the results of the latest voting round.

Advancing to the Finale:

Jamal Roberts

John Foster

Breanna Nix

Eliminated:

Slater Nalley

Thunderstorm Artis

Each finalist delivered standout performances:

Jamal Roberts: “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” and “Beauty and the Beast”

John Foster: “The Bare Necessities” and “Rainbow Connection”

Breanna Nix: “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” and “You’ll Be in My Heart”

The judges were clearly impressed with the Top 3, offering warm and supportive feedback heading into the finale on Sunday, May 18.

 Carrie’s Past Looks Also Sparked Debate

This wasn’t the first time Underwood’s appearance stirred controversy. Back in March 2025, a behind-the-scenes Instagram video showed her twirling in a bold denim-inspired ensemble with a massive bow, black-and-white ruffled skirt, and sky-high heels.

Fans quickly redirected attention from the outfit to her face — speculating about possible cosmetic changes.

“What did she do to her lips?”

“Too much filler — she was beautiful before.”

“She looks too different.”

“BIG LIPS!”

Still, others offered praise:

“She’s beautiful. Such a sweet spirit!”

“Totally fit — she looks incredible!”

Underwood’s confidence in the face of criticism remains evident. No matter the reaction, she continues to embrace bold style choices and unapologetically owns the spotlight.

 Miranda Lambert’s Guest Performance Draws Mixed Reactions

Underwood wasn’t the only country star under the microscope. On May 4, Miranda Lambert performed her hit “Kerosene” as both guest mentor and featured artist. While some fans applauded the fiery performance, others weren’t impressed.

“She was giving bare minimum stage presence — and I love that for her.”

“Plugged my ears the whole time. Can’t stand her!”

“Why did Carrie look so bored during Miranda’s set?”

Others focused on Lambert’s weight loss and looks, saying she “looked amazing” while critics labeled her an “energy drainer.”

 What’s Next?

The American Idol Season 23 finale airs Sunday, May 18 at 8 PM ET on ABC, featuring a star-studded lineup, unforgettable performances, and the crowning of this year’s Idol champion.

Whether or not Carrie Underwood returns next season remains to be seen — but one thing is certain: her presence keeps fans talking long after the music stops.

🎥 Watch all the performances, judge reactions, and behind-the-scenes moments from Disney Night and get ready for the most anticipated finale yet.