American Idol 2025 Top 8 Revealed: A Night of Stunning Performances, Surprise Exits & Rising Stars

The May 4 episode of American Idol Season 23 delivered a whirlwind of emotions, talent, and unforgettable moments during its special “Ladies’ Night” themed live show. The Top 10 contestants took the stage to perform songs by iconic female artists—guided by none other than country superstar and guest mentor Miranda Lambert.

But the night wasn’t just about performances. With live voting open during the show, fans had the final say on who would move forward and who would be sent home. By the end of the evening, host Ryan Seacrest revealed the Top 8, and the results left fans both thrilled and stunned.

John Foster Stuns With Bonnie Raitt Classic

Opening the night was John Foster, who delivered a charismatic and confident take on Bonnie Raitt’s “Something to Talk About.” Although initially nervous to perform in front of his childhood crush Miranda Lambert, he quickly found his groove thanks to her mentorship. Judges praised his growth, with Carrie Underwood saying, “You’re working the stage more, connecting more, and America can feel that.”

Kolbi Jordan Surprises with Stevie Nicks Tribute

Kolbi Jordan took a bold approach with Fleetwood Mac’s “The Chain,” diverging from expected ballads by Whitney Houston or Patti LaBelle. Luke Bryan applauded her boldness and charisma, but unfortunately, the risks didn’t pay off in votes.

Josh King Brings Blues Power to Adele Hit

Blues artist Josh King tackled Adele’s “Rolling in the Deep,” impressing judges with his emotional delivery and instrumental versatility. Richie and Underwood praised his all-in attitude and powerhouse vocals.

Breanna Nix Channels Adele with Fire

With Lambert’s help, Breanna Nix performed “Water Under the Bridge” and delivered one of the night’s most electrifying moments. Lionel Richie was in awe of her vocal strength, while Underwood called it “the perfect diva moment.”

Canaan James Hill Honors Carrie Underwood

Canaan took a leap with his performance of “Love Wins,” stepping outside his gospel comfort zone to honor Underwood. She praised his interpretation of the song’s spiritual message but sadly, the performance wasn’t enough to keep him in the competition.

Thunderstorm Artis Delivers Emotional Adele Cover

Thunderstorm impressed the judges with a soul-stirring rendition of Adele’s “When We Were Young,” earning him praise from Richie and what Bryan called his “favorite Thunderstorm performance so far.”

Slater Nalley Surprises With Reba Classic

Slater took on Reba McEntire’s “Whoever’s in New England” and raised eyebrows in the best way. Luke Bryan praised him for taking risks and showcasing unexpected range.

Jamal Roberts Reinvents Carrie Underwood’s “Undo It”

Jamal turned Underwood’s breakup anthem into a soul-infused showcase of artistry and vocal control. Richie called his presence “mesmerizing,” while Underwood was left smiling and unfazed by minor lyrical slips.

Mattie Pruitt Touches Hearts With Miranda Lambert Tribute

Closing the night was Mattie Pruitt, who performed “The House That Built Me” and played guitar for the first time on stage. The vulnerability paid off, with Underwood admitting she was fighting back tears.

The Top 8: Who Made It Through

After 22 million votes were cast, Ryan Seacrest revealed the eight contestants moving forward:

Breanna Nix
Mattie Pruitt
Jamal Roberts
John Foster

Josh King
Gabby Samone
Slater Nalley
Thunderstorm Artis

Unfortunately, Platinum Ticket winners Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan were eliminated, leaving fans in shock.

With only a few episodes left, the race to crown the next American Idol is tighter than ever. The Top 8 will return to the stage soon, and if this episode proved anything, it’s that no one is safe, and every vote counts.

Tune in next Sunday at 8/7c on ABC for more unforgettable performances and emotional moments as the journey continues!