ESPN analyst Monica McNutt has stirred up a considerable amount of controversy after discussing Caitlin Clark, the standout player for the Indiana Fever, during a recent interview.

McNutt’s remarks regarding Clark’s popularity, especially among young girls, have led to widespread backlash from fans. In September 2024, McNutt sparked a different kind of controversy when she stated that Clark deserved only 60% of the credit for the Fever’s playoff success, which many fans interpreted as diminishing Clark’s outstanding rookie performance. This previous comment, coupled with McNutt’s early pick for Angel Reese as Rookie of the Year, added fuel to the fire.

During a sit-down with BBC’s Katty Kay, McNutt discussed Clark’s immense popularity and its connection to her being seen as a role model for many young girls, particularly in terms of race.

McNutt noted that Clark’s image resonated with a wide demographic, largely due to her background as a white athlete from a small town in the middle of America. “She represented a whole lot to a lot of people, whether that is truly what she prescribed to or not,” McNutt explained, acknowledging that the connection might not necessarily align with Clark’s personal identity.

However, McNutt’s comment quickly sparked an intense backlash on social media. Critics were upset that McNutt seemed to attribute Clark’s appeal primarily to her race. One critic pointed out that the same logic could be applied to young black girls who look up to black athletes, while another quipped about the historical popularity of white basketball stars like Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, and LeBron James. Others expressed frustration with McNutt’s tendency to make controversial statements, questioning why she continues to appear on ESPN.

Despite the negative reactions, some supporters of McNutt defended her remarks. They argued that McNutt’s comment about Clark’s fan base being predominantly white wasn’t completely inaccurate, especially considering Clark’s rise to fame from a less prominent program in Iowa.

One viewer noted that younger girls likely gravitated toward Clark due to her rapid success, and her story resonated with many. Others suggested that McNutt’s observation was just a commentary on the natural way fans often relate to athletes with similar backgrounds or experiences.

The debate surrounding McNutt’s comments has intensified in the past 24 hours, with the video receiving over 4.5 million views. The incident has clearly divided the WNBA community, with fans passionately debating the nuances of McNutt’s take. As the conversation continues to gain traction, it’s evident that the ESPN analyst’s statements have left a lasting impact on how fans view Caitlin Clark’s place in the league.