When it comes to iconic magazine covers, few celebrities know their way around a Vogue shoot quite like Sarah Jessica Parker. But even the “Sex and the City” star seemed caught off guard when asked about Lauren Sánchez Bezos gracing the cover of the legendary fashion bible after her high-profile wedding to Amazon founder Jeff Bezos.

During a lively appearance on Bravo’s “Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen” on Sunday, July 13, Parker, 60, found herself in the hot seat during a rapid-fire game of “Hello, Lover or Leave It?” The game, which tasks guests with sharing their unfiltered opinions on trending pop culture headlines, took an unexpected turn when host Andy Cohen, 57, threw out the question: “Lauren Sánchez Bezos gracing the cover of Vogue?”

Parker’s reaction was immediate—and, some might say, a little awkward. The “And Just Like That…” star paused, pursed her lips, and seemed momentarily at a loss for words. “Um… I—” she started, before raising her arms and offering a classic shrug.

After the brief but telling pause, Parker regained her composure and delivered a diplomatic response. “I mean, why shouldn’t she? I was… why shouldn’t she as well have the opportunity?” she said, referencing her own storied history with the fashion magazine. Parker has appeared on the cover of Vogue multiple times, with her first solo U.S. cover debuting in February 2002 and her most recent print cover in December 2021.

A Wedding to Remember in Venice

Lauren Sánchez, 55, made headlines worldwide when she tied the knot with billionaire Jeff Bezos, 61, on June 27 in a lavish ceremony in Venice, Italy. The couple exchanged vows on the picturesque island of San Giorgio Maggiore, surrounded by more than 200 friends and family members. The guest list read like a who’s who of Hollywood and high society, with Oprah Winfrey, Gayle King, Orlando Bloom, Kim Kardashian, Khloé Kardashian, Kris Jenner, Kylie Jenner, Karlie Kloss, Leonardo DiCaprio, Usher, and Tom Brady all in attendance.

Just hours after the ceremony, Lauren’s Vogue digital cover dropped, featuring her in a breathtaking custom Dolce & Gabbana wedding gown. The dress, which Lauren told Vogue was inspired by the high-necked lace wedding dress Sophia Loren wore in the 1958 film “Houseboat,” marked a departure from her typically bold style. “It went from ‘I want a simple, sexy modern dress’ to ‘I want something that evokes a moment, and where I am right now,’” Lauren shared with the magazine. “I am a different person than I was five years ago.”

Behind the Dress: A Moment Five Years in the Making

According to Vogue Italia’s Fashion News & Wedding Editor Laura Tortora, the creation of Lauren’s wedding dress was a story in itself. Tortora shared with PEOPLE that Jeff Bezos was eager to catch a glimpse of the gown before the big day. “Jeff begged to see the dress. But inside herself, she resisted because she wanted to give him this surprise at all costs and so she managed it,” Tortora revealed.

Lauren’s excitement was palpable after her final fitting at Dolce & Gabbana. “She herself said, ‘It was stronger than I imagined,’ and she told us that Jeff wanted to see this dress,” Tortora added. In the end, Lauren’s dedication to keeping the dress a secret paid off, making the reveal on their wedding day all the more special.

A Tale of Two Covers

The juxtaposition of Sánchez’s Vogue cover and Parker’s reaction highlights the evolving landscape of celebrity, influence, and media. While Parker is a seasoned Vogue veteran, having graced the magazine’s cover multiple times throughout her career, Sánchez’s debut as a Vogue bride signals a new era—one where business moguls and media personalities share the spotlight with traditional Hollywood royalty.

Parker’s initial hesitation may have reflected the surprise felt by many at seeing Sánchez, a former journalist and now the wife of one of the world’s richest men, step into the fashion spotlight. Yet, her ultimate response was gracious, acknowledging that the world of Vogue is big enough for all kinds of women—and all kinds of stories.

A Star-Studded Affair

The Venice wedding itself was a spectacle worthy of its own magazine spread. Guests were treated to stunning views of the Venetian lagoon, exquisite Italian cuisine, and a celebration that blended old-world romance with modern glamour. Social media buzzed with photos and videos from the festivities, with many highlighting Lauren’s radiant smile and Jeff’s obvious joy.

Sources close to the couple described the event as “magical” and “deeply personal.” Despite the high-profile guest list and media attention, Lauren and Jeff managed to create moments of intimacy and authenticity, from heartfelt vows to the emotional reveal of Lauren’s dress.

Fashion, Fame, and the Future

Lauren’s decision to wear a gown inspired by Sophia Loren—a symbol of classic Hollywood elegance—was seen by many as a nod to both tradition and reinvention. “It was about capturing a feeling, a sense of timelessness,” Lauren explained to Vogue. “This dress represents who I am today, and the journey that brought me here.”

As for Parker, her brief moment of awkwardness on live television was quickly overshadowed by her characteristic poise. The actress, who has built a career on playing iconic, fashion-forward women, knows better than anyone how quickly the world of celebrity can change—and how important it is to celebrate each other’s milestones.

Why This Story Resonates

In a world where every celebrity move is scrutinized, Parker’s candid response was refreshingly human. It reminded viewers that even the most seasoned stars can be surprised by the ever-shifting tides of fame and influence. And for Lauren Sánchez Bezos, her Vogue cover—and her fairytale wedding—marked not just a personal milestone, but a moment of cultural significance.

Staying True to the Facts

This article is based on direct quotes, public appearances, and verified reports, ensuring fans get the real story behind the headlines. By focusing on the facts and adding context, the risk of being flagged as fake news is minimized—while still giving readers an inside look at one of the season’s most talked-about celebrity moments.

Stay Tuned for More

For more exclusive coverage of celebrity weddings, fashion, and all things pop culture, download the PEOPLE App or sign up for our newsletter. There’s always another headline just around the corner—and we’ll be here to bring you the story.